WhizzNotes
Chapters

Whose Reasoning Is Correct?

Check two people's conclusions against a rule, watch for words like definitely and must, and choose between one, both or neither.

Critical Thinking 4 min read Updated 13 questions Jump to quiz Feedback

On this page

In short: In these questions, two people draw conclusions from a fact in a box. Check each person on their own: does their conclusion follow every time from the fact? Watch for strong words like definitely and must and for rules turned around, then choose one, both or neither.

The rest of this chapter is in the full course

Start your free month to read every chapter of every book, with its quiz and practice questions. No card is needed. After it, the All Books plan is $12.99 a month (see prices). Below are the chapter's mind map and three questions to try.

Turn on JavaScript to sign in and read the full chapter.

Whose reasoning
The set up
  • Fact in a box
  • Two speakers
  • One, both or neither
Method
  • Treat the box as true
  • Mark each speaker
  • Then choose
Errors
  • Rule turned around
  • Too sure
  • Using outside facts
Words
  • Strong: must, definitely
  • Soft: may, could

Quiz

Sign in to take the quiz

13 questions with instant marking. It comes with your free month or the All Books plan, and your scores are saved to your account so you can carry on from any device.

Turn on JavaScript to sign in and take the quiz.

Try 3 questions now

  1. In a "whose reasoning is correct" question, how should you treat the fact in the box?

    1. A As true
    2. B As probably false
    3. C As an opinion
    4. D As one of the speakers
    Show answer

    A: As true

    Every judgement is made against that fact.

  2. Box: "All the pencils in this tin are blue." Max says, "This pencil came from the tin, so it is blue." Is Max correct?

    1. A Yes
    2. B No, it might be red
    3. C No, the tin is blue
    4. D You cannot tell
    Show answer

    A: Yes

    Every pencil in the tin is blue, so this one is.

  3. Which word in a speaker's claim is a warning sign to check carefully?

    1. A Maybe
    2. B Could
    3. C Definitely
    4. D Possibly
    Show answer

    C: Definitely

    "Definitely" claims certainty, which needs full proof.

Thinking Skills chapters

Sign in