In short: A claim like "every A is B" is broken only by an A that is not B. So to test it, you need the missing answers in two kinds of row: rows you know are A (is it B?), and rows you know are not B (is it A?). Rows that are not A, or that are already B, can never break the claim.
The rest of this chapter is in the full course
Start your free month to read every chapter of every book, with its quiz and practice questions. No card is needed. After it, the All Books plan is $12.99 a month (see prices). Below are the chapter's mind map and three questions to try.
Turn on JavaScript to sign in and read the full chapter.
- If part Yes, then part No breaks it
- If part Yes: find the then part
- Then part No: find the if part
- Skip the rest
- Swaps the parts round
- One Yes and Yes row proves it
- One No rules it out
- One case against it
Quiz
Sign in to take the quiz
13 questions with instant marking. It comes with your free month or the All Books plan, and your scores are saved to your account so you can carry on from any device.
Turn on JavaScript to sign in and take the quiz.
Try 3 questions now
A shop claims, "Every SunSafe hat blocks the sun." Which case would prove the claim wrong?
- A A SunSafe hat that did not block the sun
- B A different hat that did not block the sun
- C A SunSafe hat that blocked the sun
- D A different hat that blocked the sun
Show answer
A: A SunSafe hat that did not block the sun
The claim is broken only by a SunSafe hat that fails. Other hats do not matter.
A company says, "None of our pencils breaks when it is dropped." Which fact disproves this claim?
- A Another company's pencil broke when it was dropped.
- B One of their pencils broke when it was dropped.
- C One of their pencils did not break when it was dropped.
- D They test only some of their pencils.
Show answer
B: One of their pencils broke when it was dropped.
One of their own pencils that broke goes against "none". The other facts do not.
Claim: "If you use Brite-Clean, the stain comes out." Test 1 used Brite-Clean, but the result (a) is missing. Test 2 did not use Brite-Clean, and the result (b) is missing. Which missing answer must be known?
- A (a) only
- B (b) only
- C Both (a) and (b)
- D Neither (a) nor (b)
Show answer
A: (a) only
Test 1 could break the claim if the stain stayed. Test 2 did not use Brite-Clean, so the claim says nothing about it.