In short: Small words like all, some, none, only and if decide what must be true. "If A then B" lets you say "not B, so not A", but not "B, so A". "Only A can do B" means anyone who does B must be A.
Before you start
- Premises and conclusions (see Arguments: Premises and Conclusions).
All, some and none
| Statement | What it means | What it does not mean |
|---|---|---|
| All cats are animals | Every cat is an animal | All animals are cats |
| Some students walk to school | At least one does | Some students do not walk (it might be all of them) |
| No fish can fly | Not even one fish flies | Nothing else flies |
| Most people like music | More than half do | Everyone does |
If ... then
"If it rains, then the match is cancelled."
Only, only if and must
"Only" points to the thing you must have.
- "Only members can use the gym." So anyone using the gym is a member. But not every member uses it.
- "You can go out only if your room is tidy." So if you went out, your room was tidy. A tidy room does not promise you will go out.
- "Whoever broke the window must have been in the yard." Being in the yard is needed. It is not enough by itself: lots of people may have been in the yard.
Strong and soft words
Watch how sure a word is.
- Strong: must, always, never, all, none, definitely, certainly.
- Soft: may, might, could, some, often, usually.
A conclusion with a strong word needs strong proof. "Some children were late" cannot prove "the children are always late".
Chains of rules: what is not possible
Some questions join several rules into a chain and ask which result is not possible.
"If Zara does not warm up, she is likely to get a cramp. If she gets a cramp, she will not finish the race. If she finishes the race, she might win a medal. Otherwise, she has no chance of a medal."
- All A are B: A inside B
- Some: at least one
- None: not even one
- A, so B
- Not B, so not A
- Not: B, so A
- Only A can B: B means A
- Needed is not enough
- must, always, never
- may, might, some
- Sure: will, cannot
- Soft: likely, might
- Not possible breaks a sure link
Quick summary
- "All A are B" does not mean "all B are A".
- "Some" means at least one. It might be all.
- From "if A then B": A gives B, and not B gives not A. Nothing else follows.
- "Only A" and "only if A" make A needed, not enough.
- Strong words (must, always) need strong proof.
- In a chain of rules, only the sure links (will, cannot, no chance) decide what is not possible; "likely" and "might" are soft.
Quiz
Sign in to take the quiz
13 questions with instant marking. It is free, and your scores are saved to your account so you can carry on from any device.
Turn on JavaScript to sign in and take the quiz.
Try 3 questions now
"All roses are flowers." Which must be true?
- A A rose is a flower
- B A flower is a rose
- C Some flowers are not roses
- D No flowers are roses
Show answer
A: A rose is a flower
Every rose is inside the flower group. The rule says nothing about other flowers.
"Some students in 5B play chess." What does this tell you?
- A Every student in 5B plays chess
- B At least one student in 5B plays chess
- C Most students in 5B play chess
- D Some students in 5B do not play chess
Show answer
B: At least one student in 5B plays chess
"Some" means at least one. It might even be all of them.
"No penguins can fly." Pip is a penguin. What follows?
- A Pip can fly
- B Pip cannot fly
- C Pip might fly
- D Nothing follows
Show answer
B: Pip cannot fly
"No penguins" means not even one.