WhizzNotes
Chapters

Strengthening and Weakening Arguments

Choose the extra fact that best supports or best damages an argument by sorting every option into strengthen, weaken, neutral or out of scope.

Critical Thinking 4 min read Updated 13 questions Jump to quiz Feedback

On this page

In short: These questions ask which new fact, if true, most strengthens or most weakens an argument. A strengthener gives extra support for the conclusion; a weakener gives evidence against it, often another explanation. Sort each option as strengthen, weaken, neutral or out of scope, then choose.

The rest of this chapter is in the full course

Start your free month to read every chapter of every book, with its quiz and practice questions. No card is needed. After it, the All Books plan is $12.99 a month (see prices). Below are the chapter's mind map and three questions to try.

Turn on JavaScript to sign in and read the full chapter.

Strengthen and weaken
If true
  • Accept it as fact
  • Judge its effect
Four labels
  • Strengthens
  • Weakens
  • Neutral
  • Out of scope
To strengthen
  • Back up a premise
  • Close the gap
  • Rule out other causes
To weaken
  • Another explanation
  • Assumption is false
  • Bad side effect
Pick the most
Relevance
  • Does it change the claim?
  • So what? test

Quiz

Sign in to take the quiz

13 questions with instant marking. It comes with your free month or the All Books plan, and your scores are saved to your account so you can carry on from any device.

Turn on JavaScript to sign in and take the quiz.

Try 3 questions now

  1. In "Which statement, if true, most strengthens the argument?", what does "if true" tell you?

    1. A Check whether each option is really true
    2. B Treat each option as a fact and judge its effect
    3. C Only true options are in the list
    4. D The argument is true
    Show answer

    B: Treat each option as a fact and judge its effect

    You do not judge whether the option is true. You judge what it would do.

  2. What does a weakener do?

    1. A Supports the conclusion
    2. B Makes the conclusion less likely
    3. C Repeats a premise
    4. D Changes the topic
    Show answer

    B: Makes the conclusion less likely

    It gives evidence against the conclusion.

  3. An option is on a completely different topic from the argument. How do you label it?

    1. A Strengthens
    2. B Weakens
    3. C Neutral
    4. D Out of scope
    Show answer

    D: Out of scope

    It is not about the argument's point at all.

Thinking Skills chapters

Sign in