WhizzNotes
Chapters

Spotting Flaws in Arguments

Name the common mistakes in reasoning, such as mixing up cause and coincidence, judging from too few cases and offering only two choices, and say which sentence shows the mistake.

Critical Thinking 5 min read Updated 13 questions Jump to quiz Feedback

On this page

In short: A flaw is a mistake that makes the conclusion not follow, even if the premises are true. Common flaws: treating two things that happen together as cause and effect, judging all from a few, offering only two choices, attacking the person, and repeating the conclusion as a reason. Name the flaw, then find the option that describes it.

The rest of this chapter is in the full course

Start your free month to read every chapter of every book, with its quiz and practice questions. No card is needed. After it, the All Books plan is $12.99 a month (see prices). Below are the chapter's mind map and three questions to try.

Turn on JavaScript to sign in and read the full chapter.

Flaws
Cause
  • Came after is not caused by
  • Look for other reasons
Samples
  • Too few
  • Not typical
Choices
  • Only two given
People
  • Attack the person
  • Wrong expert
  • Everyone does it
Circles
  • Reason repeats the conclusion
Anecdotes
  • One story is not proof
Weak analogies
  • Alike where it matters?

Quiz

Sign in to take the quiz

13 questions with instant marking. It comes with your free month or the All Books plan, and your scores are saved to your account so you can carry on from any device.

Turn on JavaScript to sign in and take the quiz.

Try 3 questions now

  1. "I ate fish for dinner and then had a bad dream. Fish gives you bad dreams." What is the flaw?

    1. A It assumes one thing caused another just because it came first
    2. B It uses too many people
    3. C It attacks a person
    4. D It gives only two choices
    Show answer

    A: It assumes one thing caused another just because it came first

    The dream may have had nothing to do with the fish.

  2. "Three kids in my class like chess, so all kids like chess." What is the flaw?

    1. A Coincidence is not cause
    2. B It judges everyone from too few cases
    3. C It attacks a person
    4. D It goes round in circles
    Show answer

    B: It judges everyone from too few cases

    Three children cannot speak for every child.

  3. "Either you join the soccer team or you will never be fit." What is the flaw?

    1. A Too few cases
    2. B It gives only two choices when there are others
    3. C Wrong expert
    4. D Going round in circles
    Show answer

    B: It gives only two choices when there are others

    You can get fit in many ways.

Thinking Skills chapters

Sign in