# Whose Reasoning Is Correct?

> Check two people's conclusions against a rule, watch for words like definitely and must, and choose between one, both or neither.

From Selective School Thinking Skills on WhizzNotes, study notes for NSW students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/whose-reasoning-is-correct/. Updated 5 November 2026.

**In short:** In these questions, two people draw conclusions from a fact in a box. Check each person on their own: does their conclusion follow every time from the fact? Watch for strong words like definitely and must and for rules turned around, then choose one, both or neither.

**Mind map**

```text
Whose reasoning
  The set up
    Fact in a box
    Two speakers
    One, both or neither
  Method
    Treat the box as true
    Mark each speaker
    Then choose
  Errors
    Rule turned around
    Too sure
    Using outside facts
  Words
    Strong: must, definitely
    Soft: may, could
```

The full chapter is for students in their free month or with a subscription: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/whose-reasoning-is-correct/

## Quiz

Try these questions from the chapter quiz.

1. In a "whose reasoning is correct" question, how should you treat the fact in the box?
   - A. As true
   - B. As probably false
   - C. As an opinion
   - D. As one of the speakers
   - Answer: A. As true. Every judgement is made against that fact.

2. Box: "All the pencils in this tin are blue." Max says, "This pencil came from the tin, so it is blue." Is Max correct?
   - A. Yes
   - B. No, it might be red
   - C. No, the tin is blue
   - D. You cannot tell
   - Answer: A. Yes. Every pencil in the tin is blue, so this one is.

3. Which word in a speaker's claim is a warning sign to check carefully?
   - A. Maybe
   - B. Could
   - C. Definitely
   - D. Possibly
   - Answer: C. Definitely. "Definitely" claims certainty, which needs full proof.

The whole chapter quiz is on the page, for signed-in students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/whose-reasoning-is-correct/#quiz
