# Testing a Claim: Which Facts Do You Need?

> Test a claim such as "it always works" by hunting only for the case that could break it, and choose which missing answers in a table you must know.

From Selective School Thinking Skills on WhizzNotes, study notes for NSW students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/testing-a-claim/. Updated 7 November 2026.

**In short:** A claim like "every A is B" is broken only by an A that is not B. So to test it, you need the missing answers in two kinds of row: rows you know are A (is it B?), and rows you know are not B (is it A?). Rows that are not A, or that are already B, can never break the claim.

**Mind map**

```text
Testing a claim
  Turn it into if ... then
    If part Yes, then part No breaks it
  Which answers to find
    If part Yes: find the then part
    Then part No: find the if part
    Skip the rest
  Only
    Swaps the parts round
  At least one
    One Yes and Yes row proves it
  Must-have lists
    One No rules it out
  Disproving
    One case against it
```

The full chapter is for students in their free month or with a subscription: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/testing-a-claim/

## Quiz

Try these questions from the chapter quiz.

1. A shop claims, "Every SunSafe hat blocks the sun." Which case would prove the claim wrong?
   - A. A SunSafe hat that did not block the sun
   - B. A different hat that did not block the sun
   - C. A SunSafe hat that blocked the sun
   - D. A different hat that blocked the sun
   - Answer: A. A SunSafe hat that did not block the sun. The claim is broken only by a SunSafe hat that fails. Other hats do not matter.

2. A company says, "None of our pencils breaks when it is dropped." Which fact disproves this claim?
   - A. Another company's pencil broke when it was dropped.
   - B. One of their pencils broke when it was dropped.
   - C. One of their pencils did not break when it was dropped.
   - D. They test only some of their pencils.
   - Answer: B. One of their pencils broke when it was dropped.. One of their own pencils that broke goes against "none". The other facts do not.

3. Claim: "If you use Brite-Clean, the stain comes out." Test 1 used Brite-Clean, but the result (a) is missing. Test 2 did not use Brite-Clean, and the result (b) is missing. Which missing answer must be known?
   - A. (a) only
   - B. (b) only
   - C. Both (a) and (b)
   - D. Neither (a) nor (b)
   - Answer: A. (a) only. Test 1 could break the claim if the stain stayed. Test 2 did not use Brite-Clean, so the claim says nothing about it.

The whole chapter quiz is on the page, for signed-in students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/testing-a-claim/#quiz
