# Arguments with the Same Shape

> Strip an argument down to its pattern with letters, then find the option that reasons in exactly the same way, mistakes and all.

From Selective School Thinking Skills on WhizzNotes, study notes for NSW students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/similar-arguments/. Updated 5 November 2026.

**In short:** Some questions ask which argument is most like the one given. Ignore the topic and write the pattern with letters, such as "all A are B, X is A, so X is B". Then write each option's pattern and choose the one that matches, including any mistake it makes.

**Mind map**

```text
Same shape
  Ignore the topic
  Use letters
    All A are B
    If A then B
  Compare patterns
    Order of parts
    Strength words
  Copy the mistake
    Turned around rule
    Same flaw
  Traps
    Same topic, new shape
```

The full chapter is for students in their free month or with a subscription: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/similar-arguments/

## Quiz

Try these questions from the chapter quiz.

1. When matching arguments, what should you ignore?
   - A. The pattern
   - B. The topic
   - C. The conclusion
   - D. The word "all"
   - Answer: B. The topic. Two arguments about different things can have the same shape.

2. "All dogs are animals. Rex is a dog. So Rex is an animal." Which pattern is this?
   - A. All A are B. X is A. So X is B.
   - B. All A are B. X is B. So X is A.
   - C. If A then B. Not B. So not A.
   - D. Some A are B. X is A. So X is B.
   - Answer: A. All A are B. X is A. So X is B.. Dogs are A, animals are B and Rex is X.

3. Which argument has the pattern "All A are B. X is A. So X is B"?
   - A. Some cars are red. My car is red. So it is fast.
   - B. All roses have thorns. This flower is a rose. So it has thorns.
   - C. If it rains, I stay in. I stayed in. So it rained.
   - D. No fish can walk. Nemo is a fish. So Nemo swims.
   - Answer: B. All roses have thorns. This flower is a rose. So it has thorns.. Roses are A, things with thorns are B, and this flower is X.

The whole chapter quiz is on the page, for signed-in students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/similar-arguments/#quiz
