# Matching Arguments: Testing Every Case

> Match clues to people, list every possible case, and test an option by pretending it is true and looking for a clash with the rules.

From Selective School Thinking Skills on WhizzNotes, study notes for NSW students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/matching-arguments/. Updated 5 November 2026.

**In short:** Matching arguments questions give clues that must all fit together. List every possible case, or pretend one option is true and follow the rules, crossing it out if that leads to a clash. The answer to "which must be true?" works in every case that fits the clues.

**Mind map**

```text
Matching arguments
  Match clues
    Fewest choices first
    Who is left over
  List the cases
    Write a table
    Check every case
  Assume and check
    Pretend it is true
    Follow the rules
    Clash means wrong
  Must be true
    Works in every case
```

The full chapter is for students in their free month or with a subscription: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/matching-arguments/

## Quiz

Try these questions from the chapter quiz.

1. Ali, Bo and Cy each have one pet: a cat, a dog or a fish. Ali has the dog. Bo does not have the fish. Who has the fish?
   - A. Ali
   - B. Bo
   - C. Cy
   - D. You cannot tell
   - Answer: C. Cy. Ali has the dog. Bo cannot have the fish, so Bo has the cat and Cy has the fish.

2. Two balls are in a bag. Each is red or green. At least one is red. Which must be true?
   - A. Both are red
   - B. One is green
   - C. There is a red ball in the bag
   - D. Both are green
   - Answer: C. There is a red ball in the bag. The cases are red and red, or red and green. Only "a red ball" is in both.

3. You pretend an option is true and reach a clash with the rules. What does that show?
   - A. The option is wrong
   - B. The option must be true
   - C. The puzzle has no answer
   - D. You should choose it
   - Answer: A. The option is wrong. A clash means the option cannot fit the rules.

The whole chapter quiz is on the page, for signed-in students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/matching-arguments/#quiz
