# Finding the Hidden Assumption

> Find the unstated idea an argument depends on, test it by flipping it, and spot answer options that wrongly turn a rule around.

From Selective School Thinking Skills on WhizzNotes, study notes for NSW students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/identifying-assumptions/. Updated 6 November 2026.
Year 11 and Year 12 boxes go deeper than the Year 10 text around them.

### Story time: The missing umbrella
Dad looks out of the window and says, "Grab your raincoat. The sky is grey."

Ella thinks about it. Dad never said "grey skies mean rain", but his advice only makes sense if he believes that. If grey skies never brought rain, the raincoat would be pointless.

That unspoken idea is an **assumption**. Every argument stands on some, and the test wants you to find them.

**In short:** An assumption is something an argument needs but does not say. To check an option, imagine it is false: if the argument falls apart, it is the assumption. When a rule says something is needed, only "without it, it cannot happen" must be true; "with it, it must happen" turns the rule around.

## Before you start

- Premises and conclusions (see Arguments: Premises and Conclusions).
- Needed and enough, and turning a rule around (see Logic Words: All, Some, None, Only and If).

## What an assumption is

An **assumption** is a gap filler. The premises go part of the way, and the assumption joins them to the conclusion.

### Worked example: Spotting the gap
"Jin practised the piano every day this month, so he will pass his piano exam."

- Premise: Jin practised every day.
- Conclusion: he will pass.
- Gap: why would practice mean passing?
- Assumption: **practising every day is enough to pass the exam.**

## The flip test

### Key idea: Is it the assumption?
Take the option and make it **false**. Then reread the argument.
- If the conclusion no longer follows, the option **is** an assumption the argument needs.
- If the argument still works, it is **not**.

### Worked example: Testing two options
"The new park will be busy, because it has a big playground."

- Option: "Children like big playgrounds." Flip it: "Children do not like big playgrounds." Now the park would not be busy. **Needed.**
- Option: "The park has a café." Flip it: "The park has no café." The argument is just as strong. **Not needed.**

## Needed things: the "must also be true" type

Some questions give one rule and ask, "If this is true, which sentence **must also be true**?" The rule often says what someone **needed**.

"To win the prize, a student must have read 20 books **and** written a review."

### Key idea: What follows, and what does not
- Ella has not written a review. So she did **not** win. **Correct.** She lacked a needed thing.
- Tom read 20 books and wrote a review. So he won. **Wrong.** Those were needed, not enough. Someone else may have won.
- Sara did not win. So she did not write a review. **Wrong.** She may have missed out for the other reason, or for none.

### Watch out: The turned-around trap
The most common wrong option turns the rule around: "all winners did X" becomes "everyone who did X won". Saying all X are Y never means all Y are X.

### Exam tip: Check both parts of "and"
If you need A **and** B, missing **either one** is enough to rule you out. If you need A **or** B, you must be missing **both**.

## Not enough reason: the missing link

Sometimes the reasons are true but **not enough** to reach the conclusion. The question may ask which extra fact is **needed**, or which sentence shows the reasons are too weak.

### Worked example: A missing link
"Liam got 100% on his spelling test, so he must be the best speller in the class."

One test score is not enough. To reach the conclusion, you would also need to know that nobody else did as well, and that one test shows who spells best. The missing link: **no other student scored as high as Liam**.

### Exam tip: Strong claims need strong reasons
"Must", "the best", "always" and "everyone" are strong claims. Check whether the reasons are strong enough to carry them.

### Challenge: Selective level: or instead of and
"You can enter the pool if you have a pass **or** pay 5 dollars." Lena did not enter the pool. What do you know? Nothing for sure: she may have chosen not to go in. But if the rule was "you can enter **only if** you have a pass or pay", then someone who entered had a pass or paid, and someone with neither did not enter.

**Mind map**

```text
Assumptions
  What it is
    Not said
    Fills the gap
    The argument needs it
  Flip test
    Make it false
    Argument falls: assumption
    Still works: not needed
  Needed things
    Missing one: cannot happen
    Having them: not a promise
  Traps
    Turning the rule around
    and versus or
  Missing link
    Reasons true but not enough
    Strong claims need strong reasons
```

## Quick summary

- An assumption is an unstated idea that joins the premises to the conclusion.
- Flip test: if making it false breaks the argument, it is the assumption.
- "Must have A and B": missing either one rules you out.
- Having what is needed does not make something certain.
- Never turn a rule around: "all who won did X" is not "all who did X won".
- If true reasons are not enough for the conclusion, look for the missing link that would make it follow.

## Quiz

Try these questions from the chapter quiz.

1. What is an assumption in an argument?
   - A. A premise that is written down
   - B. An idea the argument needs but does not say
   - C. The conclusion
   - D. A question at the end
   - Answer: B. An idea the argument needs but does not say. It is unstated, but the conclusion depends on it.

2. "Take an umbrella, because the radio says it will rain." What is assumed?
   - A. The radio's forecast can be trusted
   - B. Umbrellas are expensive
   - C. It rained yesterday
   - D. The radio is loud
   - Answer: A. The radio's forecast can be trusted. If the forecast could not be trusted, there would be no reason to take the umbrella.

3. In the flip test, what do you do to an option?
   - A. Read it backwards
   - B. Imagine it is false and see if the argument still works
   - C. Swap it with the conclusion
   - D. Count its words
   - Answer: B. Imagine it is false and see if the argument still works. If making it false breaks the argument, it is an assumption.

The whole chapter quiz is on the page, for signed-in students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/identifying-assumptions/#quiz
