# How to Tackle Thinking Skills Questions

> What the Thinking Skills test asks, the two kinds of question, a five-step method that works on every critical thinking question, and how to use your time.

From Selective School Thinking Skills on WhizzNotes, study notes for NSW students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/how-to-tackle-thinking-skills/. Updated 6 November 2026.
Year 11 and Year 12 boxes go deeper than the Year 10 text around them.

### Story time: Two ways to sit the same test
Leo and Mia sit the same practice Thinking Skills test. Leo starts reading each long paragraph from the top, then reads all four answers, then reads the paragraph again. He runs out of time with ten questions left.

Mia reads the question line first, so she knows what she is hunting for. She picks out the conclusion, guesses what the answer should look like, then crosses out the options that do not fit. When a puzzle takes too long, she guesses, marks it and comes back later. She finishes with five minutes to spare.

They are equally clever. Mia just has a method.

**In short:** Thinking Skills questions test logic, not school facts. For critical thinking questions, read the question line first, read the argument, put it in your own words if it helps, predict the answer, then cross out wrong options. For puzzles, draw a picture or table and check every option against the rules.

## Before you start

- You only need careful reading and the maths you already know: counting, adding, times tables and simple fractions.
- Have scrap paper ready. Drawing is part of the method.

## What is in the test

The Thinking Skills test of the NSW Selective High School Placement Test has **40 questions in 40 minutes**. Each question has four or five options and only one is right. That is about **one minute per question**, so speed matters as much as care.

There are two big kinds of question:

| Kind | What it looks like | Chapters |
|---|---|---|
| **Critical thinking** | A short argument, then a question such as "Which statement most weakens the argument?" | Critical Thinking unit |
| **Problem solving** | A puzzle with rules: who sits where, what comes next, how many cubes | Problem Solving and Spatial Reasoning units |

## Logic, not grammar

Critical thinking questions use long sentences, but they test **logic**, not English grammar. Do not pull every sentence apart word by word. Instead, sort the information into two piles:

- **Premises**: the reasons or facts the speaker gives.
- **Conclusion**: the point the speaker wants you to believe.

When you can see which is which, gaps and mistakes in the reasoning become easy to spot.

## The five-step method

### Key idea: Five steps for every critical thinking question
1. **Read the question line first.** It is the sentence ending in a question mark. It tells you the type of question and what you are looking for.
2. **Read the argument.** Find each premise and the conclusion.
3. **Say it in your own words.** Only if it helps. Stay close to the text, because changing it can lead you away from what it really says. This is the only step you may skip.
4. **Predict the answer.** Before looking at the options, think what the right answer should do. Treat each option as an extra sentence added to the argument and ask what it would change.
5. **Cross out wrong answers.** Remove options that are off the topic (out of scope), that the text does not support, or that do the opposite of what the question asks. Choose the best one left.

### Worked example: Using the steps
"Our class should have a fish tank. Looking after pets teaches children to be responsible, and fish are easy to care for."

**Question line:** "Which statement, if true, most weakens this argument?"

1. We need something that makes the conclusion less believable.
2. Premises: pets teach responsibility; fish are easy to care for. Conclusion: our class should have a fish tank.
3. In my words: a fish tank is a good idea because it teaches care and is easy.
4. Prediction: something showing a fish tank would not teach responsibility, or would not be easy.
5. "The school has a garden." Off the topic, cross it out. "Over the holidays nobody would be at school to feed the fish." This shows fish would not be easy to care for, so it weakens. That is the answer.

## Problem solving questions

For puzzles, the steps are a little different.

### Key idea: Four steps for a puzzle
1. **Read the question line** so you know what to find.
2. **Draw it.** A number line, a seating plan, a grid or a table.
3. **Put in the sure facts first**, then the ones that depend on them.
4. **Test the options** against every rule. Often it is quicker to check four options than to solve the whole puzzle.

## Using your time

### Exam tip: Time savers
- **Do not get stuck.** If a question takes more than about 90 seconds, choose your best guess, mark it and move on.
- **Never leave a blank.** There is no penalty for a wrong answer, so a guess can only help.
- **Cross out on paper.** Eliminating two options turns a 1 in 4 guess into a 1 in 2 guess.
- **Easy questions are worth the same marks** as hard ones, so collect them all first.

### Watch out: Using what you already know
Critical thinking questions say "if true" for a reason. Use only what the text tells you. If an option uses a fact you know from outside the text, it is usually out of scope.

### Challenge: Selective level: the question line decides
The same argument can be asked about in different ways: "Which statement most strengthens it?", "Which shows the mistake?", "Which must also be true?" The right answer changes with the question line. That is why step 1 comes before reading the argument.

**Mind map**

```text
Thinking Skills
  The test
    40 questions
    40 minutes
    No penalty for guessing
  Critical thinking
    Read the question line
    Premises and conclusion
    Predict the answer
    Cross out wrong options
  Problem solving
    Draw it
    Sure facts first
    Test the options
  Time
    Skip and come back
    Never leave a blank
```

## Quick summary

- Thinking Skills has 40 questions in 40 minutes, so about one minute each.
- Critical thinking questions test logic. Find the premises and the conclusion.
- Five steps: question line, argument, own words (optional), predict, eliminate.
- Puzzles: draw a picture or table, put in sure facts first, test each option.
- Never leave a question blank, and do not get stuck on one question.

## Quiz

Try these questions from the chapter quiz.

1. What should you read first in a critical thinking question?
   - A. The first option
   - B. The question line
   - C. The longest sentence
   - D. The last option
   - Answer: B. The question line. The question line tells you what type of question it is and what to look for.

2. Which step of the five-step method may be skipped?
   - A. Reading the question line
   - B. Predicting the answer
   - C. Putting the argument in your own words
   - D. Crossing out wrong answers
   - Answer: C. Putting the argument in your own words. Restating the argument is only for when it helps. It can lead you away from the text, so it is the one step you may skip.

3. In an argument, what is the conclusion?
   - A. A fact nobody can argue with
   - B. The point the speaker wants you to believe
   - C. The first sentence
   - D. A question
   - Answer: B. The point the speaker wants you to believe. The premises are the reasons. The conclusion is the point they support.

The whole chapter quiz is on the page, for signed-in students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/how-to-tackle-thinking-skills/#quiz
