# Spotting Flaws in Arguments

> Name the common mistakes in reasoning, such as mixing up cause and coincidence, judging from too few cases and offering only two choices, and say which sentence shows the mistake.

From Selective School Thinking Skills on WhizzNotes, study notes for NSW students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/flaws-in-arguments/. Updated 5 November 2026.

**In short:** A flaw is a mistake that makes the conclusion not follow, even if the premises are true. Common flaws: treating two things that happen together as cause and effect, judging all from a few, offering only two choices, attacking the person, and repeating the conclusion as a reason. Name the flaw, then find the option that describes it.

**Mind map**

```text
Flaws
  Cause
    Came after is not caused by
    Look for other reasons
  Samples
    Too few
    Not typical
  Choices
    Only two given
  People
    Attack the person
    Wrong expert
    Everyone does it
  Circles
    Reason repeats the conclusion
  Anecdotes
    One story is not proof
  Weak analogies
    Alike where it matters?
```

The full chapter is for students in their free month or with a subscription: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/flaws-in-arguments/

## Quiz

Try these questions from the chapter quiz.

1. "I ate fish for dinner and then had a bad dream. Fish gives you bad dreams." What is the flaw?
   - A. It assumes one thing caused another just because it came first
   - B. It uses too many people
   - C. It attacks a person
   - D. It gives only two choices
   - Answer: A. It assumes one thing caused another just because it came first. The dream may have had nothing to do with the fish.

2. "Three kids in my class like chess, so all kids like chess." What is the flaw?
   - A. Coincidence is not cause
   - B. It judges everyone from too few cases
   - C. It attacks a person
   - D. It goes round in circles
   - Answer: B. It judges everyone from too few cases. Three children cannot speak for every child.

3. "Either you join the soccer team or you will never be fit." What is the flaw?
   - A. Too few cases
   - B. It gives only two choices when there are others
   - C. Wrong expert
   - D. Going round in circles
   - Answer: B. It gives only two choices when there are others. You can get fit in many ways.

The whole chapter quiz is on the page, for signed-in students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/flaws-in-arguments/#quiz
