# Drawing Conclusions: What Must Be True

> Work out what must follow from a set of facts, tell must be true from could be true, and use a quick sketch to keep the facts in order.

From Selective School Thinking Skills on WhizzNotes, study notes for NSW students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/drawing-conclusions/. Updated 7 November 2026.
Year 11 and Year 12 boxes go deeper than the Year 10 text around them.

### Story time: The library clue
Olivia's teacher says, "Every Tuesday our class goes to the library." Later, her friend says, "Today is Tuesday."

Olivia does not need anyone to tell her the next part. "Then we are going to the library today," she says.

Nobody said that sentence out loud. Olivia joined two facts together and found something new that **must** be true. That is drawing a conclusion.

**In short:** A drawing conclusions question gives you facts and asks what follows from them. The right answer must be true whenever the facts are true. Cross out options that could be true but are not proven, options that go against the facts, and options that are off the topic.

## Before you start

- Logic words such as all, some, only and if (see Logic Words: All, Some, None, Only and If).

## Must be true, could be true

The question line usually says "Which of these **must** be true?", "Which can be **concluded**?" or "Which one do I **also know**?"

### Key idea: Three kinds of option
- **Must be true**: it follows from the facts every time. This is the answer.
- **Could be true**: it fits the facts, but the facts do not prove it. Cross it out.
- **Cannot be true**: it goes against a fact. Cross it out.

### Worked example: Three friends and their pets
"Jack, Priya and Tom each have one pet: a cat, a dog or a bird. Jack is allergic to fur. Priya's pet barks."

- Priya's pet barks, so Priya has the dog.
- Jack cannot have a furry pet, so he does not have the cat. He has the bird.
- Tom has the cat.

Every pet is now known. "Tom has the cat" **must** be true.

## Use the five steps

1. **Question line**: you need something that must follow.
2. **Read the facts.** List each one.
3. **Own words or a sketch.** For comparisons, draw a line from least to most. For seats, draw the table.
4. **Predict**: what new fact can you join together?
5. **Eliminate**: remove options that are only possible, or that break a fact.

## Comparisons on a line

When the facts compare things (taller, faster, older), put them on a line.

### Worked example: Who is fastest?
"Ali is faster than Ben. Ben is faster than Cara. Dev is slower than Cara."

Fastest to slowest: Ali, Ben, Cara, Dev.

- "Ali is faster than Dev" must be true.
- "Ben came second in the race" could be wrong: a race might have other runners.

### Exam tip: Words like most and all
"All the girls scored more than most of the boys" does not mean every girl beat every boy. Some boys could still be the top scorers. Draw two groups on the same line to check.

### Watch out: Proving more than the facts say
Facts about one class do not prove things about every class. Facts about this year do not prove things about next year. If an option is bigger than the facts, cross it out.

## "Best supported": the most likely answer

Some questions ask, "Which of the following is **best supported** by the information?" This is a little softer than "must be true". The answer is the option the facts give the **strongest reason** to believe, even if it is not proven.

### Key idea: Choosing the best supported option
- Cross out options that go **against** the facts.
- Cross out options that go **far beyond** the facts, such as "always", "everyone" or a big new claim.
- Of what is left, choose the one the facts point to most directly.

### Worked example: The basketball score
"There were 4 seconds left in the basketball game. The coach said that whoever scored the next basket would almost certainly win."

- "The scores were tied, or very close." **Best supported**: one basket could only decide the game if the scores were close.
- "The home team was 20 points ahead." Goes against the facts.
- "The players were very tired." Not supported either way.

## Comparing groups: range and average

Some questions compare whole groups with words like **every**, **most** and **the top one**, then ask about the **range** (how spread out a group is) or the **average**.

### Key idea: Draw each group as a bar
Draw one line from least to most. Each group is a bar from its lowest member to its highest.

- "**Every** A beat **every** B": A's bar sits wholly above B's. Then A's average is higher too.
- "Every A beat **most** of B": most of B sits below A, but some of B may be higher.
- "The **top** C beat the top A": C's bar reaches higher.
- A bar that stretches past **both ends** of another bar has the bigger range.

### Worked example: The reading challenge
"Every Year 3 student read more books than most Year 4 students. Every Year 6 student read more books than every Year 3 student. The top Year 4 reader read more than the top Year 6 reader."

- The weakest Year 3 reader beat most of Year 4, so some of Year 4 sit below all of Year 3.
- The top of Year 4 is above the top of Year 6, which is above all of Year 3.
- So Year 4's bar stretches below Year 3 and above Year 6: Year 4 had the **greatest range**. This must be true.
- "Year 6 read more than Year 3 on average" must be true too, because every Year 6 student beat every Year 3 student.
- "Year 4 had the lowest average" is **not** proven: a few huge readers could lift Year 4's average.

### Challenge: Selective level: groups on a line
"In a spelling contest, every Year 5 student beat every Year 4 student. The best Year 6 student beat everyone in Year 5."

Draw one line. Year 4 sits at the bottom, Year 5 above it, and the best Year 6 student above them all. So the top score belongs to Year 6. But the other Year 6 students could be anywhere, even below Year 4, so "Year 6 did best on average" is **not** proven.

**Mind map**

```text
Drawing conclusions
  The question line
    must be true
    can be concluded
    I also know
  Sort the options
    Must: the answer
    Could: cross out
    Cannot: cross out
  Tools
    Line for comparisons
    Plan for seats
    Table for who has what
  Traps
    Bigger than the facts
    Only possible
  Best supported
    Most likely, not proven
    Not against or far beyond the facts
  Groups on one line
    Each group a bar
    Bar past both ends: bigger range
    Every beats every: higher average
```

## Quick summary

- Join the facts to find something new that must be true.
- "Could be true" is not enough. The answer must follow every time.
- Put comparisons on a line and seats on a plan.
- Cross out options bigger than the facts or that break a fact.
- In a who-has-what puzzle, fix the sure facts first.
- "Best supported" means the option the facts point to most strongly, even if it is not certain.
- To compare groups, draw each as a bar on one line: the bar that stretches past both ends of another has the bigger range.

## Quiz

Try these questions from the chapter quiz.

1. "Every Friday Ms Lee's class has sport. Today is Friday." What must be true?
   - A. Today is a holiday
   - B. Ms Lee's class has sport today
   - C. Ms Lee's class has art today
   - D. It will rain
   - Answer: B. Ms Lee's class has sport today. Join the two facts: Friday means sport.

2. "All the apples in the bowl are red. This apple came from the bowl." What follows?
   - A. This apple is red
   - B. This apple is green
   - C. The bowl is red
   - D. All red apples are in the bowl
   - Answer: A. This apple is red. Every apple in the bowl is red.

3. Which kind of option is the answer to a "must be true" question?
   - A. One that could be true
   - B. One that goes against a fact
   - C. One that follows from the facts every time
   - D. The longest one
   - Answer: C. One that follows from the facts every time. "Could be true" is not enough.

The whole chapter quiz is on the page, for signed-in students: https://whizznotes.com/thinking-skills/drawing-conclusions/#quiz
